Porting Rust to WebAssembly

I recently spent some effort trying to make reproto run in a browser. Here I want to outline the problems I encountered and how I worked around them. I will also provide a number of suggestions for how things might be improved for future porters.

A big chunk of the wasm story on Rust currently relies on stdweb.

Needless to say, this project is incredible. stdweb makes it smooth to build Rust applications that integrates with a browser.

There’s a ton of things that can be said about that project, but first I want to focus on the porting efforts of reproto.

Getting up to speed and shaking the tree

The best way to port a library is to compile it.

For Rust it’s as simple as installing cargo-web and setting up a project with all your dependencies.

All it really needs is a Cargo.toml declaring your dependencies, and a src/main.rs with extern declarations for everything you want compiled.

For reproto, that process looks like this:

# Cargo.toml

# skipped

reproto-core = {path = "../lib/core", version = "0.3"}
reproto-compile = {path = "../lib/compile", version = "0.3"}
reproto-derive = {path = "../lib/derive", version = "0.3"}
reproto-manifest = {path = "../lib/manifest", version = "0.3"}
reproto-parser = {path = "../lib/parser", version = "0.3"}
reproto-backend-java = {path = "../lib/backend-java", version = "0.3"}
reproto-backend-js = {path = "../lib/backend-js", version = "0.3"}
reproto-backend-json = {path = "../lib/backend-json", version = "0.3"}
reproto-backend-python = {path = "../lib/backend-python", version = "0.3"}
reproto-backend-rust = {path = "../lib/backend-rust", version = "0.3"}
reproto-backend-reproto = {path = "../lib/backend-reproto", version = "0.3"}

stdweb = "0.3"
serde = "1"
serde_json = "1"
serde_derive = "1"
//! src/main.rs

extern crate serde;
extern crate serde_derive;
extern crate serde_json;
extern crate stdweb;

extern crate reproto_backend_java as java;
extern crate reproto_backend_js as js;
extern crate reproto_backend_json as json;
extern crate reproto_backend_python as python;
extern crate reproto_backend_reproto as reproto;
extern crate reproto_backend_rust as rust;
extern crate reproto_compile as compile;
extern crate reproto_core as core;
extern crate reproto_derive as derive;
extern crate reproto_manifest as manifest;
extern crate reproto_parser as parser;

fn main() {

Finally we want to add a Web.toml, which will allow us to specify the default target so we won’t have to type it out all the time:

# Web.toml

default-target = "wasm32-unknown-unknown"

Now the project should build by running cargo web build.

For tracing down where dependencies come from, I relied heavily on cargo-tree.

When you do encounter a problem cargo tree can quickly determine how a given package was pulled in:

cargo tree
├── reproto-backend-java v0.3.13 (file://<home>/repo/reproto/lib/backend-java)
│   [dependencies]
│   ├── genco v0.2.6 (*)
│   ├── log v0.3.9
│   │   [dependencies]
│   │   └── log v0.4.1
│   │       [dependencies]
│   │       └── cfg-if v0.1.2
... snip

Big numbers

My project is structured into many different modules, each loosely responsible for one aspect of the solution.

The first module where I encountered problems was core.

The num crate by default pulls in rustc-serialize, which fails like this:

853  |     fn encode<S: Encoder>(&self, s: &mut S) -> Result<(), S::Error>;
     |     ---------------------------------------------------------------- `encode` from trait
1358 | impl Encodable for path::Path {
     | ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ missing `encode` in implementation

error[E0046]: not all trait items implemented, missing: `decode`
    --> <registry>/src/github.com-1ecc6299db9ec823/rustc-serialize-0.3.24/src/serialize.rs:1382:1
904  |     fn decode<D: Decoder>(d: &mut D) -> Result<Self, D::Error>;
     |     ----------------------------------------------------------- `decode` from trait
1382 | impl Decodable for path::PathBuf {
     | ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ missing `decode` in implementation

There appears to be a trait implementation missing.

Opening up the specified line (1382) reveals that rust-serialize has platform-specific serialization for PathBuf:

impl Decodable for path::PathBuf {
    #[cfg(target_os = "redox")]
    fn decode<D: Decoder>(d: &mut D) -> Result<path::PathBuf, D::Error> {
        // ...
    fn decode<D: Decoder>(d: &mut D) -> Result<path::PathBuf, D::Error> {
        // ...
    fn decode<D: Decoder>(d: &mut D) -> Result<path::PathBuf, D::Error> {
        // ...

Interestingly enough, this is something I’ve touched on in a previous post as a portability concern.

In rustc-serialize, paths are not portable because not all platforms have serializers defined for them! impls being missing for a specific platform wouldn’t be a big deal if platform-specific bits were better tucked away. As it stands here, we end up with an incomplete impl Decodable which is a compiler error.

If the entire impl block was conditional it would simply be overlooked as another missing implementation. In practice this would mean that you wouldn’t be able to serialize PathBuf easily, but this can be worked around be simply not using it.

Due to the current state of affairs, the easiest way to deal with it was simply to disable the default features for the num-* crates. A bit tedious to add everywhere, but not a big deal:

# ...

num-bigint = {version = "0.1", default_features = false}
num-traits = {version = "0.1", default_features = false}
num-integer = {version = "0.1", default_features = false}

There is no filesystem

I lie, there kind of is. Or at least there can be. But for our current target wasm32-unknown-unknown there isn’t.

This means that all of your sweet code using std::fs simply won’t work.

//! src/main.rs

extern crate stdweb;

use std::fs;

fn test() -> String {
    fs::File::create("hello.txt").expect("bad file");

fn main() {

    js! {
        Module.exports.test = @{test};

Taking this for a spin, would result in an unfortunate runtime error:

wasm + fs

To work around this I introduced a layer of indirection. My very own fs.rs. I then ported all code to use this so that I can swap out the implementation at runtime. This wasn’t particularly hard, seeing as I already pass around a Context to collect errors. Now it just needed to learn a new trick.

Finally I ported all code that used Path to use relative-path instead. This guarantees that I won’t be tempted to hit any of those platform-specific APIs like canonicalize, which requires access to a filesystem.

With this in place I can now capture the files written to my filesystem abstraction directly into memory!

Ruining Christmas with native libraries

Anything involving native libraries will ruin your day in one way or another.

My repository component uses ring for calculating Sha256 checksums. The first realization is that repositories won’t work the same - if at all - on the web. We don’t have a filesystem! At some point it might be possible to plug in a solution that communicates with a service to fetch dependencies. But that is currently not the goal.

This realization made the solution obvious: web users don’t need a repository. I moved the necessary trait (Resolver) from repository to core, and provided a no-op implementation for it. The result is that I no longer depend on the repository crate to have a working system, sidestepping the native dependency entirely in the browser.


Revenge of the Path

I thought I had seen the last of Path. But url decided to blow up in my face like this:

error[E0425]: cannot find function `path_to_file_url_segments` in this scope
    --> <registry>/src/github.com-1ecc6299db9ec823/url-1.6.0/src/lib.rs:1934:32
1934 |         let (host_end, host) = path_to_file_url_segments(path.as_ref(), &mut serialization)?;
     |                                ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ did you mean `path_to_file_url_segments_windows`?
error[E0425]: cannot find function `file_url_segments_to_pathbuf` in this scope
    --> <registry>/src/github.com-1ecc6299db9ec823/url-1.6.0/src/lib.rs:2057:20
2057 |             return file_url_segments_to_pathbuf(host, segments);
     |                    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ did you mean `file_url_segments_to_pathbuf_windows`?
error: aborting due to 2 previous errors
error: Could not compile `url`.

Yet again. Paths aren’t portable.

The url crate wants to translate file segments into real paths for you. It does this by hiding implementations of file_url_segments_to_pathbuf behind platform-specific gates. Obviously there there are no wasm implementations for this.

An alternative here is to use something like hyper::Uri, but that would currently mean pulling in all of hyper and its problematic dependencies. I settled for just adding more indirection and isolating the components that needed HTTP and URLs into their own modules.

"All problems in computer science can be solved by another level of indirection" — David Wheeler

What’s the time again?

chrono is another amazing library, I used it in my derive component to detect when a string looks like a datetime.

Unfortunate for me, chrono depends on time. Another platform-specific dependency!

error[E0432]: unresolved import `self::inner`
 --> <registry>/src/github.com-1ecc6299db9ec823/time-0.1.39/src/sys.rs:3:15
3 | pub use self::inner::*;
  |               ^^^^^ Could not find `inner` in `self`
error[E0433]: failed to resolve. Could not find `SteadyTime` in `sys`
   --> <registry>/src/github.com-1ecc6299db9ec823/time-0.1.39/src/lib.rs:247:25

/// snip...

error: aborting due to 10 previous errors
error: Could not compile `time`.

Because the derive feature was such a central component in what I wanted to port I started looking for alternatives instead of isolating it.

My first attempt was the iso8601 crate, a project using nom to parse ISO 8601 timestamps. Perfect!

error[E0432]: unresolved import `libc::c_void`
  --> <registry>/src/github.com-1ecc6299db9ec823/memchr-1.0.2/src/lib.rs:19:5
19 | use libc::c_void;
   |     ^^^^^^^^^^^^ no `c_void` in the root
error[E0432]: unresolved import `libc::c_int`
  --> <registry>/src/github.com-1ecc6299db9ec823/memchr-1.0.2/src/lib.rs:21:12
/// ...

error: build failed

On no…

Ok, it’s time to pull out cargo-tree.

$ cargo tree

# ...
├── iso8601 v0.2.0
│   [dependencies]
│   └── nom v3.2.1
│       [dependencies]
│       └── memchr v1.0.2
│           [dependencies]
│           └── libc v0.2.36
# ...

So nom depends on memchr, an interface to the memchr libc function. That makes sense. nom wants to scan for characters as quickly as possible. Unfortunately that makes nom and everything depending on it unusable in wasm right now.

The easiest route ended up being to write my own function here.

Make things better

In the following sections I try to summarize how we can improve the experience for future porters.

Make platform detection a first class feature of Rust

If you look over the error messages encountered above, you can see that they have one thing in common: The are all unique.

This is unfortunate, since they all relate to the same problem: there is a component X that is hidden behind a platform gate. When that component is no longer provided, the project fails to compile.

Wouldn’t it be better if the compiler error looked like this:

error[EXXXX]: section unavailable for platform (target_arch = "wasm32", target_os = "unknown"):
  --> <registry>/src/github.com-1ecc6299db9ec823/rustc-serialize-X.X.X/src/serialize.rs:148:1
148 |         #[platform(target_arch, target_os)] {
    |                    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ - platform defined here
    |             impl Decodable for path::PathBuf {
    |                 #[cfg(target_os = "redox")]
    |                 fn decode<D: Decoder>(d: &mut D) -> Result<path::PathBuf, D::Error> { .. }
    |                 #[cfg(target_os = "unix")]
    |                 fn decode<D: Decoder>(d: &mut D) -> Result<path::PathBuf, D::Error> { .. }
    |                 #[cfg(target_os = "windows")]
    |                 fn decode<D: Decoder>(d: &mut D) -> Result<path::PathBuf, D::Error> { .. }
    |             }
    |         }

It works by detecting when your platform has a configuration which does not match any existing gates, providing you with contextual information of why it failed. This means that the matching would either have to be exhaustive (e.g. provide a default fallback), or fail where the matching actually occurs.

This is much better than the arbitrary number of compiler errors caused by missing elements.

Transitive feature flags

This is the first exercise I’ve had in explicitly disabling default features. Sometimes it can be hard. Dependency topologies are complex, and mostly out of your hand.

This suggestion is heavily influenced by use flags in Gentoo, and would be a controversial change.

The gist here is that I can enable a feature for a crate and all it’s dependencies. Not just directly on that crate. This way it doesn’t matter that a middle layer forgot to forward a feature flag, you can still disable it without too much hassle.

Different crates might use the same feature flag for different things. But it begs the question: are we more interested in patching all crates to forward feature flags correctly, than we are patching crates which use the wrong flags?


This was a lot of work. But much less than I initially expected. The wasm ecosystem in Rust is really on fire right now, and things are improving rapidly!

I’m actually really excited over how well it works. Apart from a small number of expected, and even smaller number of unexpected dependencies. Things just work.

In summary:

So to leave you, feel free to try out reproto in your browser using the new eval app:


UPDATE #1: Here is the relevant PR in chrono to make time an optional dependency. Please make your voice heard if this is something you want! For nom, memchr support for wasm was merged in December, unfortunately that leaves existing libraries behind until they are upgraded.